Posted in Mobile, Website Design by Toby Davies | 2 comments

More than ever people are accessing content on the move, with mobile devices fast becoming our primary way of accessing information.

Mobile vs Desktop User Projections, 2007 - 2015

If you want people to buy your products, use your service, locate you or contact you, a mobile optimized website has arguably become the best tool available.

But there’s still a debate that many people are struggling with – which approach is best: responsive web design, a dedicated mobile site or a mobile app?

As you’ll see below, each approach has its own advantages and disadvantages.

Responsive Web Design

Responsive web design is an approach that adjusts website content and layout using CSS3 media queries to access factors such as screen size, platform and orientation. The same basic HTML can be used to display content on devices as varied as desktop PCs, tablets, mobile devices and web TVs.

Advantages of Responsive Web Design

  1. Lower costs – you only need to develop and maintain one website
  2. Consistency – your site contains the same basic content, across varying platforms, providing users with a consistent experience
  3. Single domain/URL – sharing content is made easier with no device related redirection necessary

Disadvantages of Responsive Web Design

  1. Not fully optimized – unless you use a mobile-first approach your content will not have been fully optimized for mobile devices
  2. Slower performance – mobile pages often have the same, or even larger, file sizes than their desktop counterparts
  3. Usability issues – mobile users often wish to perform different tasks to desktop users and may be accustomed to mobile-specific user interfaces

Dedicated Mobile Site

A dedicated mobile site is a separate version of your website designed exclusively for mobile devices. The most common implementation is for the mobile sites to add a prefix or suffix to the main domain (e.g. example.com becomes m.example.com) and users are automatically redirected to the mobile site if they access the website via a mobile device.

Advantages of a Dedicated Mobile Site

  1. Tailored content – separate mobile and desktop content with navigation customized for the mobile users
  2. Speed – optimize and streamline the site for the mobile user experience
  3. Quick development – if you already have an existing website, a separate mobile-only site can often be built and launched quickly at fairly low expense

Disadvantages of a Dedicated Mobile Site

  1. Multiple domain/URL – may have implications for SEO, and sharing content on social media becomes an issue
  2. Requires redirection – mobile users will be redirected to the optimized view, and vice versa, adding additional page load time
  3. Extra work – you’ll have two different sets of content to manage and maintain

Mobile App

Mobile apps are small programs that reside on mobile devices and fulfill sales, marketing or training objectives by delivering a useful tool to your target market. Apps tend to be small, self-contained and focused on solving one unique task.

Advantages of a Mobile App

  1. Fast – apps can load in seconds and are faster than both responsive and dedicated mobile websites
  2. Offline availability – apps do not require a connection so your content is always available even when the user is offline
  3. Native mobile features – your app can utilize native features such as cameras and GPS location

Disadvantages of a Mobile App

  1. Requires download – less than 20% of brand apps are downloaded more than 1000 times
  2. Maintenance – apps require lots of maintenance to keep users engaged and to adapt to frequent operating system changes
  3. Platform specific – apps are limited to mobile platforms (iPhone/iPad, Android, Blackberry, Windows 7) and require additional promotion as users won’t stumble across them on search engines

If you’d like to discuss how Digivate can help you optimize your mobile website, please get in touch and we’ll be happy to help.

About Toby Davies

Lead Designer

View all posts by Toby Davies

Comments (2)

  1. john clarke -

    Your post has given a straight forward message. Thanks.

  2. Kalidu -

    Agree with John Clarke. Good post. Thanks.

Leave Comment

* Required field